Marcus Naylor and Joshua Schaer.

Marcus Naylor and Joshua Schaer.

Naylor, Schaer vie for open judicial seat

Candidates in contested Northeast Electoral District race answer questions about injustice and more.

  • Friday, October 26, 2018 8:35am
  • News

Marcus Naylor and Joshua Schaer are running against each other in the only contested Northeast Electoral District race, for Judge Position 1. The division includes Issaquah, Sammamish, Bellevue, Redmond, Woodinville and parts of unincorporated King County. Retiring Judge Janet Garrow currently holds the seat.

Please provide a brief biography.

Marcus Naylor: Marcus and his wife Simona reside in Sammamish with their two children, Bianca and Lucas; they have lived on the Eastside for over 30 years. Marcus was born in South Korea, lived in an orphanage until age nine, then was adopted by loving American parents who were educators. With their support and commitment to public service, Marcus became an attorney and has faithfully served the public by ensuring equality and access to justice for everyone. He is currently a supervising attorney to 10 lawyers for the King County Department of Public Defense.

Joshua Schaer: A 30-year Eastside resident, and the parent of two children in the Issaquah School District. Graduated from the University of Washington with B.A. and J.D. degrees; first to achieve concentration tracks of study in both Intellectual Property and Health Care Law; founded Technology Law Society student organization. Attorney for 17 years, representing clients in criminal and civil actions. Pro tem judge for 11 years in District Court. Prevailed on cases in the State Supreme Court, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, each division of the State Court of Appeals, and numerous trial courts. Twice elected to the Issaquah City Council; chair of King County Eastside Transportation Partnership in 2015, chair of Council Infrastructure Committee. Served on Bellevue College Foundation Board, taught Sunday school for 10 years, volunteered for Skyline H.S. Mock Trial Team, University of Washington Law School Moot Court, and with my children’s sports. Decided to run for an open seat on the District Court to continue helping others on the Eastside; endorsed by many local leaders and judges.

What do you believe qualifies you to be a judge?

Naylor: Marcus brings 26 years of unmatched criminal and civil experience to the bench. He has appeared in courts all around King County, including municipal courts, district courts, superior courts as well as Court of Appeals. Additionally, Marcus has been a part-time judge for over 10 years, presiding over every type of case, both criminal and civil for the district courts of King County. Having appeared both as a practitioner and judge in district court, he has the unique experience and knowledge necessary in efficient administration of justice. Marcus has treated everyone appearing before him with dignity, patience and respect.

Schaer: In addition to broad legal experience, I have a passion for correcting injustice and a track record of dedicated public service. I am the only candidate who worked as a public defender in the Eastside courtrooms where I would serve as a judge. Attorneys know that I am thorough yet efficient, adhering to the law yet always respectful, and I have adjudicated all types of cases in the District Court.

Can you explain your judicial philosophy in plain English?

Naylor: Marcus’ judicial philosophy is to carefully apply the law to the set of facts that each case brings. The law may be the same, but each case brings its own unique set of facts, therefore, the interpretation and application of the law, unfettered by the judge’s own beliefs and values, will result in more just results for the parties. The courts must do its best to interpret the law, not legislate new policies.

Schaer: The majority of interactions between the public and legal system occur in the District Court. Although court calendars are often overloaded with complex matters, I believe that every individual must be treated with respect, given an opportunity to present his or her case, and provided with an explanation of my ruling. I will take work home or conduct research during a break in order to obtain the right outcome. Whether someone is facing a criminal charge, litigating a small claim, or challenging a traffic ticket, that person should rest assured I am listening, applying the law to the facts, and reaching a just result.

How do you define injustice, and how do you deal with it if you confront it in your courtroom?

Naylor: Marcus defines injustice in its simplest term — an act of wrong or unfairness that creates absence of justice in the court. Injustice, in whatever form, must not be endorsed by a judge or allow it to exist in the courtroom. Injustice permeates our courtrooms through racial, sexual, gender and economic biases. Therefore, judges must actively work to remove those biases in the courtroom and improve the quality and fairness of their courts. The judges, through education and training, must hold all accountable in removing biases in the courtroom.

Schaer: Injustice occurs when the court process is unfair, biased or not based on the law. We need more judges who will take the time to better understand the circumstances that brought someone into court. After joining the District Court, I will fight against injustice by striving to protect civil rights, making reasoned decisions based on precedent, and facilitating greater access to equal justice for all. Additionally, bringing the Community Court into other Eastside cities beyond Redmond would help remedy injustice; this innovative approach to restorative justice puts participants on a path to success through human services and treatment agencies. In turn, we can reduce the possibility of repeat offenses and improve community safety.

More in News

Despite concerns, homelessness authority moves towards final Seattle vote

Seattle’s homelessness committee aligned the city’s plan with King County’s.

King County’s current climate action plan was adopted in 2015 and has provided a blueprint for reducing emissions and preparing for climate change. File photo
King County approves environmental justice provision

An update to the King County climate action plan should include an… Continue reading

Homelessness authority approved by King County, awaits Seattle vote

The agreement would consolidate emergency services for people experiencing homelessness.

The King County Courthouse is located at 516 Third Ave. in downtown Seattle. Photo courtesy of King County
Council approves $600,000 to increase security at King County Courthouse

The funding will be split evenly between increasing deputies, security and social services.

Victims, law enforcement speak about King County Courthouse conditions

An entrance to the courthouse was closed after an assault.

In this September 2019 photo, George Kirkish, owner and founder of Palouse Winery on Vashon-Maury Island, pours a glass of wine for Lori Coots during tasting room hours. (Kevin Opsahl/Sound Publishing)
King County Council approves controversial winery, brewery ordinance

After five years, the county has updated regulations surrounding alcohol production and tasting.

Issaquah City Hall. File photo
Utility assistance program to launch in January

New aid available for low income residents as tax, rate increases approach.

For the 15th year, Jacksons Food Stores are matching donations dollar-for-dollar in support of the annual Gift of Peace campaign to help end domestic violence. Photo courtesy of Fiona Gwozdz
15th annual Gift of Peace campaign works to help end domestic violence

All dove sales go to support Washington State Coalition Against Domestic Violence (WSCADV).

Washington Low Income Housing Alliance is among supporters of statewide “just cause” legislation to protect tenants in Washington. However, some landlords say removing the ability to quickly remove tenants limits their ability to get rid of problem renters. (Courtesy image)
Tenant advocates prepare for another push in Olympia

Following wins in Burien and Federal Way, just cause evictions are on the 2020 Legislative agenda.

Most Read